Why Former Strictly Star James Jordan Says the Judges Are Picking and Choosing Who Gets Penalized?

Two people on Strictly Come Dancing

Former Strictly Come Dancing professional James Jordan has criticized the show’s judging panel for what he describes as inconsistent rule enforcement, arguing that some couples are penalized for technical infractions while others go unchallenged.

Jordan, who appeared as a professional dancer on the BBC series from 2006 to 2013, shared his perspective following Saturday night’s live show on November 14, during which judges Craig Revel Horwood and Anton Du Beke questioned Vito Coppola and Lacey Turner’s Foxtrot routine, suggesting it contained too many open sections and resembled an American Smooth.

Strictly Come Dancing's Dani Dyer and Nikita Kuzmin

James Jordan Calls for Consistent Judging

Speaking to WalesOnline via WhichBingo, Jordan said he supports strict adherence to ballroom and Latin rules—provided every partnership is held to the exact same standard.

“It seems very unfair to me that they’re only picking on certain people. If they’re going to do it, they have to be consistent and enforce the rules for everybody. Don’t let anyone get away with it,” Jordan said. “If you’re going to pick on one person, you have to pick on everybody. The judges can’t pick and choose when they enforce the rules. It happens all the time at the moment, where it never used to.”

Jordan also pointed to Dani Dyer and Nikita Kuzmin being reprimanded for illegal lifts while alleging that other pairs have overlooked dance requirements without facing similar scrutiny. “I’m all for the rules, and the rules should be clear to the people at home as well: if they do lifts in certain dances, they’re going to be marked down,” he added. “But they just do it whenever they want, it seems, which is a bit of a joke for me. You have to pull everyone up. It can’t be one rule for one couple and another rule for somebody else.”

Vito Coppola

Jordan Praises Vito Coppola for Defending His Choreography

During Saturday’s broadcast, Revel Horwood told Coppola and Turner that “Foxtrot is not an open dance,” prompting Coppola to respectfully point out that competition guidelines allow up to 30% open choreography alongside 70% traditional Foxtrot.

Jordan applauded Coppola for standing his ground while taking full responsibility for the routine so Turner would not shoulder the criticism. “I thought it was great that Vito stood up to Craig. I think the professional dancers should do that more,” Jordan said. “He did it in a very nice way, saying he has massive respect for Craig, but he takes it on the chin, and it’s his job as a pro to do the choreography, so it’s not her fault. That’s very true.”

Strictly judges

source: compiled from various sources

Related Posts

Vito Coppola Breaks His Silence on Strictly’s Blackpool Results After Finishing at the Bottom of the Leaderboard

Strictly Come Dancing professional Vito Coppola has shared an emotional thank-you message with viewers after he and celebrity partner Lacey Turner avoided the dance-off and secured their…

Two Former Strictly Pros Question Whether Vito Coppola and Carlos Gu’s Routine Fit a Sunday Evening Broadcast

Former Strictly Come Dancing professional Brendan Cole has weighed in on the debate surrounding Vito Coppola and Carlos Gu’s recent group performance, arguing that the routine crossed…

Prince Harry Sparks Royal Speculation With Perfectly Timed Interview Announcement

Prince Harry has appeared in a newly released promotional video for an upcoming interview, drawing attention from royal watchers because of its timing alongside Prince William and…

Anton Du Beke Hints a Strictly Come Dancing Star Could Soon Quit After Admitting It’s Getting a Bit Much

Strictly Come Dancing may be gearing up for an unexpected exit, according to one of the BBC show’s longest-serving stars. Judge Anton Du Beke recently revealed that…

Will Best and Dianne Buswell Miss Out on Blackpool After a Tense Dance-Off

The latest results show on BBC’s Strictly Come Dancing delivered high drama and heartfelt goodbyes as television presenter Will Best and his professional partner Dianne Buswell were…

The Shocking Strictly Result That Has Fans Accusing Judges of Ruining the Competition

Strictly Come Dancing viewers took to social media in frustration following the seventh results show of the 2026 series, questioning how actress Jaime Winstone and professional partner…