Brooks & Dunn were honored at the 60th Annual CMA Awards on Wednesday night, but the tribute celebrating the country duo quickly became a talking point among fans. While several artists took the stage to perform their biggest hits, some viewers were left questioning whether the tribute captured the sound and spirit they expected.
The tribute came before Brooks & Dunn received the Willie Nelson Lifetime Achievement Award, which was presented by Taylor Swift. The country stars have spent more than three decades in the industry and hold the record for the most CMA wins in history.

Halestorm opened the tribute with a rock-heavy version of “Boot Scootin’ Boogie,” led by Lzzy Hale. The performance immediately divided viewers, with some fans enjoying the unexpected change while others felt a hard rock band was not the right choice for a Brooks & Dunn tribute at the CMA Awards.
“Whoever decided this should happen should be fired,” one viewer wrote.
Another fan felt the duo deserved a more traditional country tribute, saying they should have received “something that actually keeps country music country.”
Some viewers also focused on the reactions from Ronnie Dunn and Kix Brooks during the performances. Cameras repeatedly showed the duo watching the artists from the audience, and their expressions quickly became part of the online conversation.
One fan joked that “the wife’s face said it all,” while another said, “They didn’t have to say anything. Their faces stated plenty.”
However, not everyone thought the performance was a disaster. Some fans pointed out that Halestorm’s version was not completely unfamiliar to Brooks & Dunn. The rock band appeared on the duo’s 2024 album Reboot II, which featured re-recorded versions of their classic songs with other artists.

One viewer reminded other fans to “go back and look at Brooks and Dunn’s reboot 2 video,” noting that the duo had already welcomed Halestorm’s version of their music.
Another fan defended the rock group, writing that Halestorm is “one of the most underrated rock bands out there” and praising Lzzy Hale as a talented performer.
Still, many viewers remained unconvinced.
“I was confused as to who was screaming to begin with, when that stopped then I heard the country version,” one fan wrote.
Another said the tribute “was not good, until the last when Brad and Luke performed.”

A separate viewer called the performance “different, not the best way to honor these two,” while another simply wrote, “It was awful!! Love Brooks and Dunn!!!”
The Halestorm performance was followed by Marcus King, Brothers Osborne, HARDY, and Luke Bryan and Brad Paisley, who performed “Rock My World (Little Country Girl),” “Hard Workin’ Man,” “Hillbilly Deluxe,” and “Play Something Country,” respectively.

The final performance from Luke Bryan and Brad Paisley also inspired a few jokes from fans because of the song choice. One viewer pointed out the irony of ending the tribute with “Play Something Country,” while another joked about the unexpected lineup.

After the performances, Taylor Swift presented Brooks & Dunn with the Willie Nelson Lifetime Achievement Award, honoring their decades-long impact on country music.
CMA CEO Sarah Trahern praised the duo for helping shape the genre over more than 30 years and for continuing to influence new generations of artists and fans.
While the tribute did not receive a unanimous reaction, the strong response showed just how much Brooks & Dunn’s music still means to country fans. Some wanted a more traditional celebration of the duo, while others appreciated seeing their songs interpreted in a completely different style.