The Voice fans are unhappy with one major issue that affected several performances during Week 2 of the Season 30 Live Shows, which ended with two singers going home.
Monday night’s episode featured the second part of Y2K Night, with the remaining seven artists from Team Kelly Clarkson and Team Riley Green competing for five spots in the Top 10. After America’s votes were counted, Anna McElroy and Cade Mower were eliminated, leaving five artists to join the five singers who advanced the previous week.

While fans celebrated the new Top 10, many were also frustrated by the song choices given to some of the singers. Several viewers felt the songs did not match the artists’ voices well enough to show their strengths.
The issue became especially clear after Anna McElroy’s elimination. She performed Faith Hill’s “Breathe,” and although many fans praised her voice and performance, others felt the song worked against her.
“Anna, this song was made for your voice sister!” one fan wrote.
Another viewer said, “I thought she did beautifully and was really surprised she didnt move fwd.”

But others were much more critical of the choice.
“Can’t touch Faith,” one fan commented.
Another wrote, “She has a beautiful voice but wrong song for her.”
A different viewer added, “I don’t think this was a good song for her voice.”
One fan even pointed to a bigger problem across the night, writing, “The song choices for multiple singers tonight didn’t do them justice.”
Fans Also Question Cade Mower’s Song Choice
Cade Mower’s elimination sparked a similar reaction. Many fans believed he deserved to make the Top 10, while others felt his song choice prevented him from showing his full potential.
“He should have definitely made too 10!!!!” one viewer wrote.
Another said, “I thought he did great he should’ve went through 💔.”

Some fans were more critical of his performance, but still blamed the song selection.
“This song did not do him justice,” one viewer commented.
Another wrote, “Wrong song for that voice.”
A separate fan added, “Lots of wrong song choices tonight.”
The frustration went beyond Anna and Cade. Some viewers also questioned song choices for other singers, with one fan saying it felt like several artists were given songs outside their vocal range or style.
For fans who supported Anna and Cade, the double elimination was especially difficult because both singers had received strong reactions from viewers throughout the season.
With Anna and Cade gone, the Top 10 is now set. Team Riley has Joe Henley and Ferryn & Brinkley, while Team Kelly has Brianna Cameron, Kyle Davis, and Koumba Diallo. They join Team Adam’s Connor Closs, Lexi Stephens, and Dakota Cohen, along with Team Queen’s Mia Knight and BigCountry.
The Top 10 will return Monday, November 23, for Dolly Parton Tribute Night.